06-12-2013, 03:13 PM
Join Date: Dec 2004
Rep Power: 53
Originally Posted by KJR
Hmm...well I'll break it down like this:
Voice - Both are distinct, but you can't top Meth's voice, it's simply addictive. - METH
Lyrics - Meth is clever but Redman is something else with his lyrics. He can be silly, smart, or absolutely ridiculous and all his words are carefully chosen to convey this - RED
Wordplay - Sort of goes into lyrics, and again it's Redman - RED
Delivery - I love both of their deliveries, but I gotta go with Red. His energy is simply infectious - RED
Flow - It's hard to touch Meth with flow, just his track (on 36 Chambers) is all the proof you need, the guy can flow - METH
Storytelling - Meth really don't tell much for stories, Redman can however. Check out "Sooperman Luva II" for proof - RED
Freestyle - I've only heard a number of freestyles from them but from the ones I did, Red was better - RED
Live Performance - Can't comment on this one
Albums - Red's got more quality albums, period. - RED
Guest Spots - I've yet to see a guest spot where Red doesn't kill it - RED
So total wise that's---
Redman - 7
Method Man - 2
Redman is better imo, but they're both great MCs.
yo props for your reply. good to see some valid input once in a while instead of the usual dumbness we see here. i agree with most of your choices.. ones i disagree with are :
Freestyle : I'd go with Mef., if he wants to Mef incorporates his multiple styles when freestyling and can go on and on.. yeah every shit he spittin aint pure freestyle but hes one of the best to link verse to verse flawlessly switchin it up a bit and tweaking things to make it sound ill that might have sounded whatever if some other rapper spitted.
Albums : Matta fact, i do agree with you on this one.. ONLY for the fact Mef has "Tical 0" in his discography.... without that you can go either way but sadly its unavoidable.
Live Performance : No one rocks a show like MEF, hands down. not that Red dont hold his shit down but like you said about Mef's flow, he takes this one as well.
Guest Spots : this one is debatable, yes RED kills all his slots but Mef does as well. i might have not been too clear but when i say guest spots, im including Mef's verses on Wu joints that are NOT his albums. it aint Mef's fault Wu has so much doper shit than Def Squad...lol