Jeter has had some good series...but when was the last time they won it all??? Seven years ago? Jeter is a good player, but I'd hardly call him great. He is a .300 hitter who wont hit more than 20 homers and wont drive in a ton of runs. He won't win any gold gloves either.
He is just solid all around...he past playoff performances and the fact he has a few rings and plays for the NYY will probably get him in the HOF....but other than that, there are alot of SS's I'd take over him.